It is estimated that about 50% of all runners will experience
an injury that will necessitate a break in their running programme
for at least one week. Most running injuries are limited to
the lower limb with injuries to the knee being the most common
at 25%. The incidence of injuries reported at other anatomical
sites includes: foot (2-22%), ankle (9-20%), lower leg (2-30%),
hip (2-11%) and lower back (3-11%). Running injuries have
been statistically associated with previous injuries and training
errors in a review by van Mechelen 1992, of the factors commonly
implicated in the aetiology of running injuries. Anecdotally
excessive pronation has been associated with running injuries
by sports physicians.
However, there has been a lack of consensus in the literature
as to a causative association between excessive pronation
and running injuries. Furthermore biomechanists have been
unable to demonstrate changes in the running style of runners
with sports shoes that vary in the grade of motion control.
This has shed doubt on the role of sports shoes in the correction
of excessive pronation
Consequently, the future of the motion control features of
sports shoes may be limited. However, the natural selection
and continued use of sports shoes that have strong motion
control features and neutral features by runners that appear
to have excessive pronation movement and have a neutral movement
respectively, suggest that the current design of sports shoes
may not be without merit.
It may be in runners best interests to continue
to use the current sports shoe designs until they have been scientifically
proven to have a negative effect on running biomechanics and the
incidence of running injuries. In this article I will review the
dynamics that occur during the gait cycle, the current understanding
of excessive pronation and the possible mechanisms by which pronation
is thought to cause running injuries.
Gait cycle
A gait cycle may be described as the events that occur from the
initial contact of one foot to the next successive contact of the
same foot with the running surface. The gait cycle in running may
be described to have four distinct phases. In the first phase, the
first foot is in contact with the running surface and this is described
as the stance phase. During this phase the opposite foot is not
in contact with the running surface and is swinging forward. The
entire body is propelled forward through the air as a result of
the terminal events of this phase. With the termination of the stance
phase, the swing phase is described to occur. In the swing phase
both feet are lifted from the ground as the body continues to follow
the path of propulsion initiated during the preceding stance phase.
The swing phase concludes with the first contact of the opposite
limb with the running surface and the initiation of the second stance
phase. The stance phase of the opposite limb is then followed by
a second successive swing phase in which the body is then airborne
with neither foot in contact with the running surface. The successive
oscillation of the stance and swing phases of the two limbs effects
forward motion during running.